City Garage
Known for tackling weightier philosophical and political heavyweights, Santa Monica’s ever-unconventional City Garage Theatre pivots beautifully into lighter, more intimate territory with Charles L. Mee’s Limonade Tous les Jours: A Paris Love Story. Featuring a wisp of a socially unacceptable romance that trades the company’s signature Brechtian hammers for something altogether more delicate, this time out is a lyrical, evocative meditation on the persistent hunger for human connection.
Under the absolutely brilliant direction and featuring a drastic Mee-approved adaptation by City Garage’s prolific 39-year artistic director Frederique Michel, Limonade is a whimsical meditation on the unpredictable nature of romance, challenging the rigid boundaries society often places around love. Set against a backdrop that evokes a dreamy and almost cinematic romance, the production thrives on its ability to balance lighthearted charm with deeply bittersweet truths about our flawed species’ too-often culturally compromised crash through life.
When a chance encounter at a sidewalk café sparks an immediate and surprisingly connected conversation about guarded affections, haunting loneliness, and the absolute foolishness of falling in love for a second time, the result is exactly what they claim to be guarding against. What follows is a whirlwind, mai-décembre fling that felt quite like home to me personally as it evolved into a subtle, elusive dance of mutual seduction and vulnerability.
Michel draws strikingly well-calibrated performances from her cast of three, successfully mining the wit, humor, and underlying melancholy of Mee’s signature conversational prose. The heart of the production beats in the captivating dynamic between its leads.
As the free-spirited Golightly-esque Parisian Ya-Ya, Nicolet Anton delivers a performance brimming with magnetic vitality and a sharp, spirited intelligence. Rather than falling into what could be an easy trap of a superficial archetype, she injects the character with a compelling, unpredictable spark that commands the stage.
Opposite her, David E. Frank portrays the reluctantly smitten Andrew with measured vulnerability, capturing the hesitation and eventual surrender of a mature man caught off guard by an unexpected second chance at passion with a girl half his age. The chemistry between Anton and Frank is palpable, navigating Mee’s rhythmic avant-garde dialogue with easy and fluid grace.
While the central romance dictates the plot, the true lifeblood of this production resides in the spectacular contribution of Cruz St. James. Serving double duty as the production's choreographer and a chameleonic ensemble force, fluidly stepping into roles ranging from a swift-footed waiter to a hypnotic nightclub performer called Madame Josephine, St. James delivers a textbook example of theatrical versatility.
As a performer, he possesses a magnetic presence that completely recalibrates the energy of the room whenever he steps onstage. Whether executing his own sultry, sharply stylized choreography or anchoring the show's musical transitions with striking vocal delivery, St. James elevates the multi-role ensemble into a vital living framework for the play. Rather than simple background texture, these varied characters operate as a witty, physical commentary on the central storyline of the lovers' sweeping emotions. It is a thrillingly distinct, multi-faceted performance that provides the production with its most vibrant and memorable highlights.
Charles Mee is easily one of the most iconoclastic voices in contemporary American theatre. Often asking people to refer to him simply as "Chuck," as he did when I interviewed him in 2004 to coincide with the opening of his Summertime (in which I had the great honor of playing the then-unknown Tessa Thompson’s father in the second ever production of the Boston Court Performing Arts Center), the playwright’s path to becoming a staple of the avant-garde theatrical scene is entirely unique largely because he didn't start out as a conventional theatre practitioner and radically rejects the traditional rules of playwriting.
Mee describes his plays not as tightly spun psychological realism, but as collages. He samples and repurposes found texts from a dizzying array of sources, including classical Greek tragedies (which he frequently reinvents, such as Big Love or Orestes 2.0), historical documents, Shakespearian fragments, National Enquirer articles, classical philosophy, and contemporary pop culture. He tosses these elements into a theatrical blender to create dense and often beautifully disjointed landscapes. For him, human experience isn't a neat, linear narrative; it is messy, interrupted, and flooded with competing stimuli.
As he told me back a dozen years ago during Summertime, he sees his plays a lot like life, something akin to riding a rollercoaster when it suddenly shifts or dips or makes a drastic turn, throwing you completely off-center from what you expected.
Perhaps his most controversial contribution to the theatre world is his radical stance on intellectual property. In the early 1990s, Mee launched “The (Re)making Project,” posting the full texts of all his plays online for free and issuing a public manifesto inviting artists to pillage his work:
"Please feel free to take the plays from this website and adapt them, ruin them, change them, hand them to your friends, put your own name on them... cut them up, reshape them, write your own plays inspired by them, or do whatever you like with them."
With our production of Summertime, our director Michael Michetti mentioned to Chuck how much he loved a particular one-scene appearance in his previous play Wintertime, which features the same family, when a pizza deliveryman casually sticks around to talk about his killing of his entire family.
Chuck said, "Put it in." When Michael seemed puzzled, the writer elaborated, telling him to feel free to take the scene and add it somewhere in our production, which we did featuring the incredible Patrick Gallo in the role.
Mee views theatre as a continuous historical conversation, arguing that Greek tragedians stole from mythology, Shakespeare stole from Holinshed, and therefore modern theatre artists should steal from him. His deeply political and historical sensibilities stem from his first career. After writing early off-off-Broadway plays in the 1960s, he took a 20-year hiatus from theatre to support his family.
During that time, he worked as a professional historian and author, writing acclaimed, definitive nonfiction books on international diplomacy, power dynamics, and American history (such as Meeting at Potsdam and The Marshall Plan). He also served as the editor-in-chief of the arts and culture magazine Horizon. When he finally returned to the stage in the mid-1980s, collaborating with choreographer Martha Clarke on Vienna: Lusthaus, he brought that massive historical canvas with him.
While his intellectual pedigree is formidable, a Charles Mee play is rarely dry or pedantic. He frequently infuses his work with an intense, almost breathless sense of joy and physicality. It is common for a Mee script to suddenly demand that the entire cast burst into an elaborate synchronized dance, sing a classic pop song, or erupt into physical slapstick. He routinely strips away traditional plot mechanics to focus purely on the intense, erratic emotional states of his characters: their longing, their sudden violent passions, and their desperate pursuit of love. Given City Garage's long-standing devotion to European avant-garde and text-driven deconstructed theatre, Mee's poetic, collage-driven style is a perfect fit for their artistic wheelhouse.
In an inspired directorial choice, Michel introduces a rich musical framework that completely reshapes the production’s atmosphere, turning a straiqht play into a fascinating piece of contemporary musical theatre. By embedding specific French torch songs into the core concept of the play, they function as vital narrative extensions rather than traditional musical breaks. It is a bold, inventive piece of theatricality that honors the script's fluid structure while giving the audience a beautifully textured auditory experience. Rather than treating these musical numbers as mere decorative interludes to break up the text, Michel elevates them into crucial storytelling pillars. This layered, collage-like approach to the soundscape feels entirely organic to the piece, perfectly deepening the emotional resonance of the staging.
Hence the most incredible part of this time out is what Michel has done to adapt and recreate the script itself. The pair has maintained a very close relationship according to Michel’s cohort and City Garage producer and production designer Charles A. Duncombe, and she let the playwright know early on what she had in mind—something about which he was very enthusiastic. In putting this version together, she added monologues from others of Chuck’s plays that seemed in the spirit of things, including this last speech is from his Tunnel of Love that she gave to Cruz as the waiter to deliver—a huge departure since in the original Limonade, the character is a non-speaking Vietnamese transplant to Paris:
"Sometimes you don't see the other person at first.
And then suddenly you do.
You sense something in one another.
You might not even know what it is.
In fact, you never know,
the connection is so deep,
beneath the place where language even starts.
And then, if you let the moment pass, it is past forever.
And then what you never know is:
was this the great love or not?
Was this the one great love
that you've just missed.
Because each of us is given only one great love in life.
That's what al the poets have known.
We've forgotten it in our times.
I think we get too caught up in our daily lives.
But people used to know:
you are born,
you have one great love,
you die.
There's nothing else to life.
That's why, in Romeo and Juliet,
after they find their love,
they die.
Because that's the truth of it:
birth, love, and death,
that's all there is.
Your great love may come at the beginning of you life,
or in the middle,
or near the end.
Or not at all.
But there is only one
and if you miss it,
you've missed it forever.”
As I said, this particularly hit home to my partner Hugh and especially to me, the décembre of our amazing love story, since we have defied all our friends' early opinions (now changed, I assure you) and societal influences to benefit from a remarkable 13-year-plus relationship regardless of the massive 42-year age difference between us. Thanks to Michel’s genius contribution as director and adapter, this version of Chuck Mee’s originally melancholic ending for Limonade Tous les Jours, while deftly honoring Mee’s intricate melange-ike mixture of dialogue, utilizes his atmospheric shifts to create an environment that feels both deeply intimate and larger than life to me.
The result is a remarkable staging that understands the play's inherent poetry, allowing moments of quiet reflection to breathe just as effectively as its bursts of theatrical joy. It is an enchanting evening of theatre that transports its audience into a dreamlike state, offering a beautifully stylized escape that lingers in the mind long after the final curtain.