Boston Court Performing Arts Center
Reviewing my dear friend Jessica Kubzansky’s beautifully appointed revival of Tennessee Williams' The Night of the Iguana was a decision I actually only made this morning, since I adamantly said I would be coming as a TicketHolder and LA Drama Critics Circle voter and not as a critic. After almost 39 years reviewing theatre, I have to say this was the one time I wasn’t sure if I could possibly be objective about a production.
You see, it was 64 years ago this month when I was cast in the small part of a Mexican beachboy in the original pre-Broadway run of Iguana at the Blackstone Theatre in Chicago during the summer of 1961, surely making me the only 14-year-old Danish Jew to ever be considered for such a role.
Maybe young Latino actors weren’t as available in Chitown way back then in a very different time or perhaps it had to do with the fact that I had worked with the associate producer in another production in New York several years earlier. Viola was in fact someone privy to the horrific event I had lived through the previous year and perhaps she thought a little therapy watching art being created was just what I needed.
Either way, I sprayed massive amounts of jet black Streak ‘n Tip on my blondie little noggin eight times a week and slathered on the Texas Dirt, a powdered makeup that created an iridescent bronze complexion and was banned several years later because it actually contained lead mined in Texas. With my history of cancer, sometimes I wonder if this production had anything to do with me being a five-time survivor of the Big C, especially since I had to cover myself in the toxic stuff all the way to my lower tanline and from my top of my legs down since in one scene I wore speedos that today would probably fit over one thigh.
Pancho was a very minor role, but one I accepted eagerly knowing I’d be working with the great director Frank Corsaro and a topnotch cast that included Bette Davis, Margaret Leighton, and Patrick O’Neal. When Iguana opened in the fall of 1961, two weeks before my 15th birthday, it was an extremely different play then it eventually became, the first production Tenn created without the guidance and mentorship of director Elia Kazan. It was Kazan who had molded his wild imagination and obsessiveness into something more or less coherent in all of Tenn’s previous triumphs, including A Streetcar Named Desire and A Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, both of which had been awarded the Pulitzer Prize for Drama.
The big problem was, Tennessee saw Iguana as his first comedy, but the Chicago critics certainly did not. Soon after our opening night, the nightmarish Miss Davis had our amazing director fired and Tenn himself came into Chicago from St. Louis where he had been recovering from gangrene after a dog bite.
From the moment he arrived, racing around with a walker but still somehow able to find inappropriate places to make his hands wander on a too-early world-weary teenage kid wearing some mighty scanty costuming, every day the cast would meet on the stage of the cavernous and historic Blackstone, reworking and rewriting and trying out new things that evening.
Since I had such tiny part and was still trying to slog through high school in the nearby suburb of Elmhurst where my parents lived, I was told I didn’t need to be at these rehearsals, something to which I responded with a resounding au contraire. This was an extraordinary opportunity to observe theatrical history being molded right before my eyes and I didn’t miss a moment. I would sit in the front row of the empty theatre and not move a muscle through the entire process of watching The Night of the Iguana become the great classic of the American 20th-century theatre as it is now recognized today.
All that said, the idea of reviewing a production of Iguana, even with the incredible vision of the Boston Court’s artistic director Jessica Kubzansky holding the reigns, was not something which gave me any enormous sense of confidence, especially as I consider the Boston Court one of my most cherished theatrical homes in Los Angeles, having appeared there as an actor three times since its inception in 2003 and it was also the place that hosted a showing of my New Orleans paintings and Tennessee Williams portraits during former co-artistic director Michael Michetti's bold revisioning of Streetcar several years ago.
I hearby officially change my mind. This production is absolutely a glowing representation of a truly magnificent work of art. It is beautifully designed, brilliantly acted, and directed with an obvious passion for honoring the words and poetry of Williams more than I’ve ever seen accomplished in a previous mounting of the classic since our groundbreaking production—which of course ended up extremely successful after Tennessee’s five-week rewrite session which culminated in closing our Chicago run just before Crissmiss of 1961.
Iguana quickly transferred to New York for its Broadway debut later that month, a journey I was not asked to join, partially because of my age and partially because when Davis found out how old I was, she wasn't too pleased about the opening segment where she and I were discovered in a cabana at the back of the stage performing more than just the usual amount of stagecraft.
I began as Poncho, the character who beds Maxine at the top of the play and when the then-unknown Christopher Jones was hired to replace me in New York, James Farantino, the other unknown actor who originally played the second beachboy, took over my role. That summer, however, I was contacted and told Jones was off to Hollywood under contract and I was asked to replace him for six weeks during my summer vacation from school. So eventually, I ended up playing both Pancho and Pedro, Maxine’s boytoys who did little more than look fetching and retrieve the guests’ luggage for their stay at the rundown Costa Verde Hotel on the west coast of Mexico at Puerto Barrio.
So that’s the story of my history with Iguana and now may I say, what Kubzansky, along with her artistic and design team at the Boston Court, have done to breath life back into this production is quite impressive.
Do I have my druthers about some choices here? Of course I do. Iguana has been a part of my life for 64 years and it’s hard not to remember some of what was originally discovered and evolved during the play’s reworking in Chicago—not to mention looking back at the real rain that fell from the fly tower at the end of Act One or Lincoln, the live iguana Jimmie and I actually brought onstage and tied up under the veranda for all to see as the play unfolded.
One major change happened in the process as Tenn rewrote and we performed the changes: Davis’ role, the lusty hotel owner Maxine, gradually became a lesser character and the part of Hannah, the Nantucket spinster played by Margaret Leighton, definitely became the pivotal role in the production, something that surely helped Davis find the chops to play a monster like Baby Jane Hudson only a few years later.
As Maxine at the Boston Court, the casting of bigger-than-life African American actress Julanne Chidi Hill is a stroke of genius. She brings something to the role I’ve never seen before, including in the performance of Davis and subsequent Maxines such as Maureen Stapleton, Shelley Winters (with whom I worked when I came back into the show that summer), Sylvia Miles, and even Ava Gardner in the classic 1964 John Houston movie, perhaps her most radiant film appearance of all. None of these noted actors ever quite found the moments of basic loneliness and humanity Hill brings to the role.
As the most pivotal characters, however, Riley Shanahan and Jully Lee, although both phenomenal actors and incredibly well cast in these multifaceted roles, for me both lack something that perhaps only I or a few people left who were part of the original production (Lane Bradbury, who originated the role of Charlotte, and I are now the only surviving members of the original cast) or perhaps those few who saw it still with all their faculties and among the living might grasp.
Of course, Margaret Leighton would be a hard act to follow anywhere, much to Davis’ extreme vexation and leading her to leave the show after only four months in New York. Maggie was not only nominated but won the Tony Award in 1961 for Best Actress and Deborah Kerr in the film version should have won an Academy Award for her best performance ever on film.
Lee has a great capacity for understanding Hannah, but there was something so magically ethereal about Maggie’s Hannah, a madonna quality that I have never seen any actor ever find again in the role. Lee is wonderful but there’s a pragmatism and schoolteacher-ishness about her performance that, although interesting and also valid, I personally felt missed the unearthly, gossamer delicacy that makes the role one of the most entrancing on any stage. If the initial impression of Hannah is not of fragility and wondering how she could possibly continue to exist in the harsh world of her travels, when her monumental strength becomes apparent, the effect is far less impactful.
In the role as the Reverend T. Lawrence Shannon, Shanahan is also quite arresting but again, what’s missing for me from my unique perspective is how shattered and shaky Patrick O’Neal was right from the character’s first entrance back in 1961. There’s a healthiness and a vitality in Shanahan that I found disturbing from the get-go that leaves Shannon’s final tortured, overwrought monologue only able to land somewhere where O’Neal began.
It’s a monologue that provided one of the most memorable moments in our production because it was so jarringly frantic and rapidly spewed out that you had to fight to hear the words, leaving audience members to wonder if it would end with Shannon falling over dead by the time Hannah comes back onstage and says she’s been listening from around the corner the whole time.
One of my favorite Los Angeles actresses and a treasure to our community is Ann Noble, who is glorious in almost everything I’ve ever seen her do. Her Judith Fellowes, however, the stiff-backed leader of the tour of middle-aged schoolteachers Shannon is conducting through Mexico from the Baptist Female College in Blowing Rock, Texas, is a bit too broad and cartoonlike to work completely. This role has always been a juicy assignment for any actor, but somehow Noble misses some subtlety to make us also feel an underlying sense of empathy for Miss Fellowes rather than just find her a character brought along for comic relief—although I’ll bet Tenn might’ve found her take to be absolute perfection.
Aside from my minor quams, all again strictly from a very idiosyncratic perspective from my history with the play, this is a magnificent production, a tremendous tribute to the greatest playwright and perhaps the greatest poet of the last century.
It is a production that also could not be more timely in some respects. I remember at age 14 realizing Shannon‘s speech about the destruction of the environment and about people worshiping their god as a “senile delinquent,” made my little head explode and helped me see and understand the world from a whole new perspective.
This dynamic mounting of The Night of the Iguana, under the leadership of one of our best Los Angeles directors, is among the finest stage productions to hit any Los Angeles stage this year.