Ahmanson Theatre
The beginnings of the 65-year-old musical Once Upon a Mattress were modest indeed. First developed in a much shorter version as part of a workshop at the now-defunct Tamiment Playhouse's adult summer camp in the Poconos, it opened first off-Broadway in 1959 before transferring to Broadway later that same year.
To say that Jay Thompson, Marshall Barer, Dean Fuller, and composer Mary Rogers humorous adaptation of Hans Christian Andersen’s 1835 fairy tale The Princess and the Pea is a minor effort has always been a given; what made it a huge success back then was the meteoric emergence of its star in her first leading role: one previously unknown Miss Carol Burnett.
It’s impossible to imagine Mattress without someone cast as Princess Winnifred any less dynamic than Burnett, who throughout her nearly seven-decade career has always been a tough—no impossible—act to follow. Indeed in its original production, when she left the show and was replaced by The Brady Bunch’s acerbic housekeeper Ann B. Davis, the production closed after a mere eight performances.
Even in its first national tour featuring Dody Goodman and later Imogene Coca in the role, Mattress never got the same response without Burnett and proved to be a difficult sell despite the iconic Buster Keaton along for the ride as the mute King Sextimus the Silent.
I would suspect when the current incarnation of the musical began as a concert staging for New York City Center’s Encore! series with a new adaptation written by The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel’s multiple Emmy-winning Amy Sherman-Palladino, there wasn’t prior thought about it moving to Broadway, let alone embark on a national tour.
What primarily made it a reality was finding an actor capable of all but channeling Burnett—and that would be double-Tony-winning Broadway superstar Sutton Foster appearing as Fred. Her performance in the musical’s pivotal role, half-Burnett and half-Judy Canova, is almost singlehandedly what this revival is all about; if she hadn’t agreed to travel with the production here to the Ahmanson, I doubt if it would have been booked.
What’s the old adage about making a silk purse? In a show long relegated to being presented in high schools and community theatres, this Mattress is mighty comfy and about as slickly silken as it could be. Under the delightfully tongue-in-cheek direction of Encore's Tony-nominated Lear deBessonet and featuring some truly inspired performances in the musical’s principal roles, it somehow manages to overcome all the reasons it hasn’t received a large scale new production in over six decades.
Foster is a true triple-threat as a singer, dancer, and most of all a brilliant physical comedian. All long gawky legs, akimbo elbows, goofy expressions, and acing a majorly disheveled appearance, she gets away with things no one else could—except of course Carol Burnett herself. As another character quips, she appears to have so many teeth “it’s like you ate a piano,” something that could be (and has been) said about the original Princess Fred as well.
One purposely long and extended scene in which Foster devours an entire bowl of grapes without swallowing could also easily rival her predecessor playing Eunice Higgins or Alice Portnoy, something of which audience members seated in the first two rows and not gifted with Blue Man plastic ponchos could certainly attest.
In an inspired bit of casting, Foster is perfectly complimented by one of the Broadway stage’s other most gifted performers, Michael Urie, playing the lovably hapless Prince Dauntless. As a team who clearly enjoys working with one another, the pair makes this all fresh and winning.
Urie is especially endearing as he tries to navigate set designer David Zinn’s many onstage staircases with utmost slapstick aplomb and in a hilarious one-person “duet” with the show’s other best asset, David Patrick Kelly, who delivers a showstopping turn as Dauntless' aphonic father the King.
Ana Gasteyer is also a standout as a Margaret Dumont-esque Queen Aggravain, as is Kevin Del Aguila as the court’s resident Wizard and Daniel Breaker as the Jester who narrates the story.
What makes this work best and get the better of a dated old warehouse that was never too good in the first place is the decision to embrace its obsolescence rather than improve it. Zinn’s intentionally flat and flimsy-looking set, Andrea Hood’s primary-colored costuming, Justin Townsend’s lighting so bright it hurts, and featuring musical director Annbritt duChateau and her sprightly orchestra visible upstage behind the action, are all aspects quickly reminiscent of one of those cheesy old-fashioned TV variety specials that aired in early 1960s starring someone like Andy Williams or Dean Martin. Unlike most modern musicals relying on hydraulics and video projections rather than movable set pieces, Camelot-style royal banners are flown in from above, furniture is carried on and off by ensemble members, and a black vaudeville-style wall lowers when things need to change behind it.
Despite Sherman-Palladino’s identifiably contemporary touches, the book is basically just as old-style and Rogers’ score is just as forgettable as ever, but there are lots of tongue-in-cheek innuendos to catch, including calling out things mentioned that haven’t yet been invented, as well as topical references surely added wherever the tour lands—in this case asides about traffic on the 405 and a telling reference to one of the male dancer’s sexuality by mentioning he lives in Silverlake.
The company of comic veterans also allowed themselves a few nanoseconds of breaking up SNL-style on opening night, as when another ensemble member obviously had a hard time staying in character when Foster silenced him by raising a leg and sticking her foot over his mouth. Whether such moments are spontaneous or scripted I can’t say, but they definitely add to the fun in a production that refuses to take itself too seriously.
There are lotsa reasons to see Once Upon a Mattress while it’s stopped here. If nothing else, it’s a golden opportunity to experience the magical talent of folks such as Sutton Foster, Michael Urie, and David Patrick Kelly, worldclass performers who are becoming—no, already are—theatrical legends in their own time.