Rogue Machine Theatre
As with everything glaringly apocalyptic descending upon our poor maligned planet since the beginning of 2025, from a shocking political takeover of our divided country’s democracy to unconscionable genocide happening elsewhere on distant shores to terrorism both foreign and domestic to natural disasters close to home caused by climate change, the Los Angeles theatre community also got off to a bumpy start.
Thank Geebus for the indomitable spirit of two venerable LA theatrical institutions, the Road Theatre Company and now Rogue Machine, both of whom helped assuage the bad taste left by a shockingly clueless takedown of a great classic.
Rogue Machine’s Evanston Salt Costs Climbing, its second mounting of a future chef-d'oeuvre by Will Arbery, whose Pulitzer finalist Heroes of the Fourth Turning was one of the best on any local stage in 2023, clearly solidifies that this writer—alongside the Road’s own undeclared resident playwright Steve Yockey—will be among the O’Neills and Williamses and Millers of the 21st century.
As a kid, my homebase was Elmhurst, Illinois, about 20 miles from Evanston, and having later attended school there at Northwestern, I can verify that midwestern winters are nothing short of brutal and, from what my family still there tells me, it’s only gotten worse since my early years there back when dinosaurs still roamed the earth.
Evanston Salt Costs Climbing takes place in the university town-dominated former wetlands and swampy community that shares the north shore of Lake Michigan with downtown Chicago about 12 miles south. This is where two bluecollar truck drivers make their living during the treacherous winter months spreading salt on the area’s notoriously dangerous roads.
It’s a difficult life for the suicidal Peter (Michael Redfield), stuck in a humdrum marriage with a wife he dreams about off-ing, and his partner Basil (Hugo Armstrong), a Greek immigrant who spends his evenings alone writing fanciful stories, usually set in the warmth of summer, and standing by his kitchen window “playing with his dick.”
Their deadend jobs are in danger of becoming even more deadend as their supervisor Jane Maiworm (Lesley Fera), a deputy administrator for the city’s public works department, attempts to bring Evanston Public Works into a more technologically advanced future by one day implementing a new system of heated permeable street tiles that will render Peter and Basil’s jobs obsolete.
Evanston Salt is remarkably quirky and ironically funny but above all, it's an incredibly newsworthy play, introducing us to four achingly needy ordinary people—Maiworm’s majorly dysfunctional stepdaughter Jane Jr. (Kaia Gerber) being the fourth—desperately trying to find a way to connect with one another and navigate the disintegrating world around them.
Arbery's characters share one common trait: although each longs for that kind of illusive human kinship, they are all too terrified to confront—or more than that, let anyone even get a glimpse into—their individual potentially shameful worldview to be successful at making a connection.
Coupled with the familiar yet indescribable feeling that there’s something lingering underneath everything that “wants us all to die,” these modernday Beckettian characters crash through their lives alternating between monumental moments of near-euphoric hope and petrifying doubt—and no one understand their plight better than their director Guillermo Cienfuegos.
I kept thinking during the performance what it must have been like for Cienfuegos to read Arbery’s densely absurd yet hauntingly topical script for the first time. It would be hard to imagine the idea of directing such an idiosyncratic piece of theatrical indulgence could have been anything but an intimidating concept, but it proved to be a challenge Rogue Machine’s exceptionally sturdy artistic director handled with consummate skill and an equally quirky sense of unstoppable theatricality.
Cienfuegos, like the playwright, obviously has a highly developed imagination. Arbery’s script has no stage directions or suggestions detailing how some of Salt’s most unwieldy visual challenges can be accomplished. I know—I looked. The long one-act has no discernible scene change notifications, which makes Cienfuegos’ staging even more amazing, particularly on the Matrix’s often difficult wide and shallow playing space.
Every one of his designers are completely in line with his vision. Mark Mendelson’s set ingeniously switches from the workers’ break room to Maiworm’s living room to the freezing Chicago outdoors seamlessly, anchored in the middle by a workable rusty industrial garage door which noisily lifts to reveal the cab and glaring headlights of Peter and Basil’s salt truck.
Dan Weingarten’s lighting and Michelle Hanzelova-Bierbauer’s projection design perfectly accentuate the bland surroundings dominated by the blizzardy Chicago winterscape, making me wonder along the way if the freezing Colony Theatre-esque temperature inside the Matrix might have been intentional to make us wish we had been handed out a few of costumer Christine Cover Ferro’s coziest woolen scarves and beanies.
All of this, complimented by Christopher Moscatiello’s clattering, echoing, blustering sound design, conspires to bring Salt’s arduous Chicago winter to life.
Of course, everything here would be for naught without this production’s spectacular quartet of performers, who as an ensemble I suspect will be hard to beat for award consideration at the end of the year.
Redfield and Gerber have a harder task in many ways due to the lack of any kind of discernible character arc for their woebegone supporting characters, but both hold their ground beautifully playing off Fera and Armstrong, two of Los Angeles’ most noteworthy and beloved stage veterans.
If Redfield’s casually suicidal Peter is not able to find a way to painlessly pull the plug, he wants nothing more than for his wife to shut up and his Domino’s pizza to be delivered on time, while Gerber’s Jane Jr., “completely bored and terrified every second” of her life, only desires to marry a famous singer and live in a warm tropical place—if only she could leave the living room couch.
As Maiworm, Fera is suitably cheerful and grandly encouraging to the malcontent others as the city official who genuinely cares for her employees despite knowing her ambition to make her department’s task more in tune with the future, particularly since Basil seems adept at going down on her when caught up in their secret decidedly non-work-related relationship. Under the composure, however, it’s not hard to picture Maiworm in mid-scream on Edvard Munch’s infamous bridge.
Still, it is Armstrong whose work absolutely overshadows everything else about this production—and I don’t mean that as a negative observation. This guy is consistently and courageously daring in every role he assumes, someone who onstage you can’t stop watching in all his intricate subtle nuances, and yet he is often over-the-top in a way only he can get away with. He is not only someone easy to call out as a wonderful actor, Armstrong epitomizes what constitutes a truly great artist.
Above everything that makes this an unforgettable experience, however, the true star of Salt is Will Arbery, whose inspiration for his play came while a directorial student at Northwestern, assigned to write a short play inspired by an article in the local newspaper.
What presumably survived from that exercise was this play’s title, something akin to when many years ago, while riding with a friend through the English countryside, Peter Shaffer was offhandedly told about a local story of a young boy’s inexplicable blinding of six horses in a stable where he worked. Haunted by the idea but unable to uncover any other details about the incident, he sat down and wrote a fictional account to relieve his creative OCD. The result was Equus.
One cannot help to wonder what the original newspaper piece disclosed that magically turned into Arbery’s astounding Evanston Salt Costs Climbing. It makes me want to go back to the late 60s when, returning home to the bucolic suburbs of Chicago after an extended period living and working in New York City, the front page headline of the local weekly Elmhurst Press community newspaper upon my arrival was “BOY CUTS FINGER.”
I wonder what a brilliant and worldclass talent such as Will Arbery might have created from that. Whatever it might have been, I would want be there to see it.